Issue 15 · Crosswalk
The Appeal Button
How the Structure claims and Reference links line up, claim by claim.
Reference Dependency Crosswalk
Satisfied means exposed to outside support, not proved.
This table connects each structural claim to the public reference pressure behind it. A bounded dependency is not a failure; it is an honest label.
| Structure claim | Outside support | Reference | What it does and does not cover |
|---|---|---|---|
| SL-015-01 AI burden reduction is not symmetrical. | Partly satisfied | RL-015-04, RL-015-08 | Supports workflow/adoption context, not a universal burden-reduction measurement. |
| SL-015-02 The early appeal button is a filter before assistance. | Satisfied, with limits | RL-015-03, RL-015-07 | Low awareness and procedural appeal steps support the hidden-doorway/test frame. |
| SL-015-03 A real button means workflow transfer, not a better letter. | Satisfied, with limits | RL-015-04, RL-015-05, RL-015-07, RL-015-08 | Shows why access rights and appeal pages are not the full workflow. |
| SL-015-04 The system around the model is the barrier. | Satisfied, with limits | RL-015-04, RL-015-05, RL-015-06, RL-015-07 | Supports the split ownership/procedure/authority map. |
| SL-015-05 Current tools show a category, not default burden transfer. | Bounded | RL-015-08 | Category evidence only; no success, scale, or outcome proof. |
| SL-015-06 The burden gap is a watch shape, not one universal metric. | Satisfied, with limits | RL-015-01, RL-015-02, RL-015-03 | Supports the burden-gap shape, not one shared measurement base. |
| SL-015-07 High overturns are a warning light, not proof all initial denials were wrong. | Satisfied, with limits | RL-015-02 | Overturns matter, but the documentation caveat stays live. |
| SL-015-08 Upstream reform still matters; the button is a lever, not the final reform. | Partly satisfied / hypothesis | RL-015-04, RL-015-07 | Policy rails and appeal process support plausibility; upstream pressure is not measured. |